
Nobody Bid on the Old Hastings Creamery Site. Here's Why the City Thinks That Happened
TLDR
- The former Hastings Creamery and Polka Dot Dairy properties on Vermillion Street went up for online auction.
- The auction ended Nov. 5 with zero bids on either property.
- City staff says people are interested in the land.
- Staff thinks the auction setup scared buyers off, because they couldn't get city approvals before buying.
The old Hastings Creamery site is one of the most visible spots in town. So you'd think someone would want it. But at the Nov. 12 HEDRA meeting, city staff shared a surprise. The Hastings Creamery land auction ended with no bids at all.
What Was for Sale
There were two pieces of land sold as separate "tracts" (sections):
- The former Polka Dot Dairy property. That one still has buildings on it.
- The former Hastings Creamery property. That one is now an empty commercial lot.
Together, they cover about 4 acres along Vermillion Street (Highway 61). The auction listing from Steffes Group said the land sees about 40,000 cars a day. The online auction ran from Oct. 29 to Nov. 5. You can still see the listing on the Steffes Group site.
How the Creamery Site Got Here
If you've lived in Hastings a while, you know this story. The Hastings Cooperative Creamery closed in August 2023. Then in September 2023, a huge fire tore through the old building.
For a long time, not much happened. The burned-out shell just sat there along Vermillion Street. In February 2026, the City Council finally ordered the owner to clean it up by June 15. The cleanup got done in time. By late June, green grass had replaced the piles of debris, the Hastings Journal reported.
For a lot of locals, the creamery was more than a building. KDWA talked with a former creamery worker about what the place meant to the town.
Why No One Bid
Here's the thing. City staff says interest in the land is real. Staff has talked with people who want the site. Some of them reached out to the creamery owners directly.
Own a local south metro business?
We help Dakota & Scott County businesses reach local readers. Takes 30 seconds.
Thanks β enjoy the read! π
So why zero bids? Staff thinks the auction format just didn't fit this kind of land. Here's the problem:
- At an auction like this, you basically buy it sight unseen.
- You don't get a chance to get entitlements first. Entitlements are the city approvals you need to build what you want, like zoning or a site plan.
- So a buyer could pay for the land and then find out the city won't OK their plan.
"Usually developers are looking for a little more certainty than that," staff said. That's especially true for the empty creamery lot. Most developers want to know their project can actually happen before they hand over the money.
What Happens Next
Staff said they're not sure what the next steps are. That's up to the owners. One option would be putting the land back up for sale in a different way, like a regular listing. That would let a buyer make an offer that depends on getting city approvals.
The timing could matter too. Highway 61 runs right past this land, and it's getting rebuilt in 2028 and 2029. You can read what that rebuild means for Vermillion Street.
The Bottom Line
The creamery site is clean, it's on a busy road and people want it. It just didn't sell at auction. If you're hoping for something new there, the most likely path now is a regular sale to a buyer with a real plan. That plan would then go through the city, with public meetings.
Whatever ends up there could help fill Hastings' housing and business gaps. We'll keep an eye on it. For more Hastings news, check our Hastings city page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Did anyone buy the Hastings Creamery site?
No. The online auction ended Nov. 5 with zero bids on the creamery lot or the Polka Dot Dairy property.
Where is the old creamery?
At 1701 Vermillion Street, along Highway 61 in Hastings. The nearby Polka Dot Dairy property was offered in the same auction as a second tract.
Why didn't anyone bid?
City staff thinks the auction format was the problem. Buyers had to buy without a chance to get city approvals first, and developers usually want that certainty.
Is the burned creamery building still there?
No. The cleanup and demolition were finished in June 2026. The lot is now grass.
What will go on the creamery land?
Nothing's planned yet. Any new project would need city approval, with public meetings first.




